What SHOULDN'T They Sing?

So, after spending far too long contemplating what songs the remaining 16 should sing in Week 3, I began thinking about the songs that they most definitely should NOT sing. For each contestant left in the competition, what would be the worst/most ridiculous song choice for them? Would it be Kevin Covais singing Chop Suey by System of a Down? Possibly Lisa Tucker singing Man, I Feel Like a Woman?

Here are my choices:

Ayla Brown: Short People, by Randy Newman
Ace Young: I'm Coming Out, by Diana Ross
Chris Daughtry: Making Love Out of Nothing At All, by Air Supply
Katharine McPhee: The Devil Went Down to Georgia, by Charlie Daniels Band
Kellie "The Gherkin" Pickler: Here Comes the Hotstepper, by Ini Kamoze
Elliott Yamin: Lips Like Sugar, Echo & The Bunnymen
Kinnik Sky: Don't You Forget About Me, by Simple Minds
Gedeon McKinney: Party All the Time, by Eddie Murphy
Lisa Tucker: Hell Is For Children, by Pat Benatar
Mandisa: Physical, by Olivia Neutron-Bomb
Melissa McGhee: Brand New Key, by Melanie
Kevin Covais: Groove Is In The Heart, by Dee-Lite
Paris Bennett: Cherry Pie, by Warrant
Taylor Hicks: Sussudio, by Phil Collins
Will Makar: The Real Slim Shady, by Eminem
Bucky Covington: Take On Me, by A-ha

Think you can do better? Post your choice(s) for the worst thing the contestants could sing below. You VOTE, you DECIDE!